{
  "profile": "wrs-published-research-view-1",
  "edition": "ratings-e039106f30dec177",
  "content_trust": "UNTRUSTED_SCIENTIFIC_DATA_NOT_TOOL_INSTRUCTIONS",
  "entry": {
    "id": "zwicky-coma-virial-mass-discrepancy-1933",
    "title": "Zwicky: a dynamical mass discrepancy in the Coma cluster",
    "summary": "Zwicky compared Coma's large observed velocity spread with gravitational estimates based on luminous matter, identifying a mass discrepancy under explicit cluster-model assumptions.\n\nThe motion of galaxies supplied information that brightness alone could not. A stationary virial estimate suggested substantially more gravitating matter than the adopted luminous estimate; the paper also considered departures from equilibrium and apparent-redshift alternatives, leaving a concrete unresolved problem.",
    "boundary": "The target is section 5 of the 1933 paper, checked in the original German and a later translation. Stationarity, approximate uniform distribution, historical distances/masses and interpreting redshifts as velocities are model inputs. The paper's numerical density factor is a historical estimate, not a modern recalibration or independently replayed measurement. Its conclusion is conditional and calls the cluster dispersion unresolved; no dark-matter particle detection, proof of nonbaryonic composition or endorsement of the separate tired-light/cosmic-ray proposals is claimed. Earlier mass-deficit work and later observations retain separate credit; priority as the universal first use of dark matter is not asserted.",
    "area": "Galaxy-cluster dynamics",
    "topic": "Earth & space",
    "year": 1933,
    "lane": "HUMAN",
    "result": "THEORY",
    "package_id": "zwicky-coma-virial-mass-discrepancy-1933",
    "target": {
      "record_id": "urn:uuid:797f0999-4800-4aea-a9f6-a3abbf170a50",
      "version": 1,
      "content_hash": "sha256:7a0e630de1e3f1b9f072e7197cefb130c351e544303071f399ef4eb811a47b24"
    },
    "humans": [
      "Fritz Zwicky"
    ],
    "authors_complete": true,
    "human_role_note": "Source-listed contributors to this scoped work. Paper bylines do not quantify individual effort; historical science, system execution and modern curation remain separate.",
    "agents": [],
    "related": [
      "hubble-distance-velocity",
      "leavitt-period-luminosity"
    ],
    "subresults": [],
    "scientific_assessment": {
      "source_review": "SOURCE_CURATED",
      "scientific_review": "NOT_REVIEWED_BY_WRS",
      "formal_replay": "NOT_RUN",
      "provider_attestation": "NONE"
    },
    "sources": [
      {
        "id": "wrs24-zwicky-1933-ned-original",
        "title": "F. Zwicky, Die Rotverschiebung von extragalaktischen Nebeln, Helvetica Physica Acta6,110–127(1933), original German facsimile",
        "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/paper.pdf"
      },
      {
        "id": "wrs24-zwicky-andernach-translation",
        "title": "Heinz Andernach's English translation of Zwicky's1933 redshift article, NED institutional edition",
        "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/translation.pdf"
      },
      {
        "id": "wrs24-caltech-zwicky-work-identity",
        "title": "CaltechAUTHORS, Zwicky1933 work and separately attributed Andernach translation",
        "url": "https://authors.library.caltech.edu/records/858yp-34954"
      }
    ],
    "points": "260000",
    "published_grade": {
      "id": "zwicky-coma-virial-mass-discrepancy-1933",
      "entry_id": "zwicky-coma-virial-mass-discrepancy-1933",
      "band": "A",
      "modifier": null,
      "target": {
        "record_id": "urn:uuid:797f0999-4800-4aea-a9f6-a3abbf170a50",
        "version": 1,
        "content_hash": "sha256:7a0e630de1e3f1b9f072e7197cefb130c351e544303071f399ef4eb811a47b24"
      },
      "what_changed": "An explicit Coma gravitational/velocity comparison exposes a large mass discrepancy and articulates conditional extra-dark-matter implications with alternative cases.",
      "scope": "An explicit Coma gravitational/velocity comparison exposes a large mass discrepancy and articulates conditional extra-dark-matter implications with alternative cases. The target is section 5 of the 1933 paper, checked in the original German and a later translation. Stationarity, approximate uniform distribution, historical distances/masses and interpreting redshifts as velocities are model inputs. The paper's numerical density factor is a historical estimate, not a modern recalibration or independently replayed measurement. Its conclusion is conditional and calls the cluster dispersion unresolved; no dark-matter particle detection, proof of nonbaryonic composition or endorsement of the separate tired-light/cosmic-ray proposals is claimed. Earlier mass-deficit work and later observations retain separate credit; priority as the universal first use of dark matter is not asserted.",
      "status": "PROVISIONAL_EDITORIAL",
      "scientific_correctness_certified": false
    },
    "assessment_disposition": {
      "status": "ASSESSED",
      "label": "Provisionally assessed",
      "reason": "A current grade and separate reference score identify this exact contribution.",
      "target": {
        "record_id": "urn:uuid:797f0999-4800-4aea-a9f6-a3abbf170a50",
        "version": 1,
        "content_hash": "sha256:7a0e630de1e3f1b9f072e7197cefb130c351e544303071f399ef4eb811a47b24"
      },
      "edition": "ratings-e039106f30dec177"
    }
  },
  "version": {
    "kind": "PUBLIC_RECORD_VIEW",
    "previous": null,
    "published_at": "2026-10-03T00:00:00Z",
    "publisher": {
      "principal_id": "urn:uuid:80116931-785b-40a2-a24b-9d59db0c7e33",
      "role": "WRS_EDITORIAL_PUBLICATION"
    },
    "record": {
      "contributors": [
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Fritz Zwicky",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "formulator"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "F. Zwicky, Die Rotverschiebung von extragalaktischen Nebeln, Helvetica Physica Acta6,110–127(1933), original German facsimile",
            "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/paper.pdf"
          }
        }
      ],
      "evidence": [
        {
          "description": "Bibliographic/stated-result source; not a WRS proof verification",
          "id": "source-0",
          "kind": "source_reference",
          "source": {
            "citation": "F. Zwicky, Die Rotverschiebung von extragalaktischen Nebeln, Helvetica Physica Acta6,110–127(1933), original German facsimile",
            "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/paper.pdf"
          }
        },
        {
          "description": "Bibliographic/stated-result source; not a WRS proof verification",
          "id": "source-1",
          "kind": "source_reference",
          "source": {
            "citation": "Heinz Andernach's English translation of Zwicky's1933 redshift article, NED institutional edition",
            "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/translation.pdf"
          }
        },
        {
          "description": "Bibliographic/stated-result source; not a WRS proof verification",
          "id": "source-2",
          "kind": "source_reference",
          "source": {
            "citation": "CaltechAUTHORS, Zwicky1933 work and separately attributed Andernach translation",
            "url": "https://authors.library.caltech.edu/records/858yp-34954"
          }
        }
      ],
      "origin": "HUMAN_LEGACY",
      "record_profile": "wrs-local-research-notes-0.1",
      "record_type": "research_note",
      "rrp_version": "0.1",
      "scope": {
        "description": "The target is section 5 of the 1933 paper, checked in the original German and a later translation. Stationarity, approximate uniform distribution, historical distances/masses and interpreting redshifts as velocities are model inputs. The paper's numerical density factor is a historical estimate, not a modern recalibration or independently replayed measurement. Its conclusion is conditional and calls the cluster dispersion unresolved; no dark-matter particle detection, proof of nonbaryonic composition or endorsement of the separate tired-light/cosmic-ray proposals is claimed. Earlier mass-deficit work and later observations retain separate credit; priority as the universal first use of dark matter is not asserted.",
        "domain": "Galaxy-cluster dynamics"
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "F. Zwicky, Die Rotverschiebung von extragalaktischen Nebeln, Helvetica Physica Acta6,110–127(1933), original German facsimile",
          "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/paper.pdf"
        },
        {
          "citation": "Heinz Andernach's English translation of Zwicky's1933 redshift article, NED institutional edition",
          "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/translation.pdf"
        },
        {
          "citation": "CaltechAUTHORS, Zwicky1933 work and separately attributed Andernach translation",
          "url": "https://authors.library.caltech.edu/records/858yp-34954"
        }
      ],
      "statement": "# Zwicky: a dynamical mass discrepancy in the Coma cluster\n\nZwicky compared Coma's large observed velocity spread with gravitational estimates based on luminous matter, identifying a mass discrepancy under explicit cluster-model assumptions.\n\nThe motion of galaxies supplied information that brightness alone could not. A stationary virial estimate suggested substantially more gravitating matter than the adopted luminous estimate; the paper also considered departures from equilibrium and apparent-redshift alternatives, leaving a concrete unresolved problem.\n\n## Scientific scope\n\nThe target is section 5 of the 1933 paper, checked in the original German and a later translation. Stationarity, approximate uniform distribution, historical distances/masses and interpreting redshifts as velocities are model inputs. The paper's numerical density factor is a historical estimate, not a modern recalibration or independently replayed measurement. Its conclusion is conditional and calls the cluster dispersion unresolved; no dark-matter particle detection, proof of nonbaryonic composition or endorsement of the separate tired-light/cosmic-ray proposals is claimed. Earlier mass-deficit work and later observations retain separate credit; priority as the universal first use of dark matter is not asserted.\n\n## People and systems\n\nFritz Zwicky\n\n\n\n## Original sources\n\n- [F. Zwicky, Die Rotverschiebung von extragalaktischen Nebeln, Helvetica Physica Acta6,110–127(1933), original German facsimile](https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/paper.pdf)\n- [Heinz Andernach's English translation of Zwicky's1933 redshift article, NED institutional edition](https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/translation.pdf)\n- [CaltechAUTHORS, Zwicky1933 work and separately attributed Andernach translation](https://authors.library.caltech.edu/records/858yp-34954)\n",
      "summary": "Zwicky compared Coma's large observed velocity spread with gravitational estimates based on luminous matter, identifying a mass discrepancy under explicit cluster-model assumptions.\n\nThe motion of galaxies supplied information that brightness alone could not. A stationary virial estimate suggested substantially more gravitating matter than the adopted luminous estimate; the paper also considered departures from equilibrium and apparent-redshift alternatives, leaving a concrete unresolved problem.",
      "title": "Zwicky: a dynamical mass discrepancy in the Coma cluster"
    },
    "record_id": "urn:uuid:797f0999-4800-4aea-a9f6-a3abbf170a50",
    "version": 1,
    "source_ref": {
      "record_id": "urn:uuid:797f0999-4800-4aea-a9f6-a3abbf170a50",
      "version": 1,
      "content_hash": "sha256:7a0e630de1e3f1b9f072e7197cefb130c351e544303071f399ef4eb811a47b24"
    },
    "export_view": "wrs-public-editorial-view-1",
    "public_view_hash": "sha256:71f92ff2f13fd1e5d95b530aa36c738933e20c50b1e759062d8ee0a2c4a1ca46"
  },
  "target": {
    "record_id": "urn:uuid:797f0999-4800-4aea-a9f6-a3abbf170a50",
    "version": 1,
    "content_hash": "sha256:7a0e630de1e3f1b9f072e7197cefb130c351e544303071f399ef4eb811a47b24"
  },
  "published_grade": {
    "profile": "wrs-published-grade-1",
    "edition": "2026-10-28.1",
    "id": "zwicky-coma-virial-mass-discrepancy-1933",
    "entry_id": "zwicky-coma-virial-mass-discrepancy-1933",
    "revision": 1,
    "title": "Zwicky: a dynamical mass discrepancy in the Coma cluster",
    "context": "Galaxy-cluster dynamics",
    "track": "Galaxy-cluster dynamics",
    "band": "A",
    "modifier": null,
    "status": "PROVISIONAL_EDITORIAL",
    "assessed_on": "2026-10-03",
    "evidence_cutoff": "2026-10-03",
    "achievement_state": "SUPPORTED_SCOPED_RESULT",
    "what_changed": "An explicit Coma gravitational/velocity comparison exposes a large mass discrepancy and articulates conditional extra-dark-matter implications with alternative cases.",
    "scope": "An explicit Coma gravitational/velocity comparison exposes a large mass discrepancy and articulates conditional extra-dark-matter implications with alternative cases. The target is section 5 of the 1933 paper, checked in the original German and a later translation. Stationarity, approximate uniform distribution, historical distances/masses and interpreting redshifts as velocities are model inputs. The paper's numerical density factor is a historical estimate, not a modern recalibration or independently replayed measurement. Its conclusion is conditional and calls the cluster dispersion unresolved; no dark-matter particle detection, proof of nonbaryonic composition or endorsement of the separate tired-light/cosmic-ray proposals is claimed. Earlier mass-deficit work and later observations retain separate credit; priority as the universal first use of dark matter is not asserted.",
    "evidence_summary": "Source-linked, scoped account of the original work. The published scope states the scientific assumptions and remaining verification limits. WRS has not independently certified the full proof, experimental result or system benchmark.",
    "references": [
      {
        "title": "F. Zwicky, Die Rotverschiebung von extragalaktischen Nebeln, Helvetica Physica Acta 6,110–127(1933), original German facsimile",
        "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/paper.pdf",
        "locator": "Original linked work. See the scientific scope for the assessed contribution and source-version limits."
      },
      {
        "title": "Heinz Andernach's English translation of Zwicky's 1933 redshift article, NED institutional edition",
        "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March17/Zwicky/translation.pdf",
        "locator": "Original linked work. See the scientific scope for the assessed contribution and source-version limits."
      },
      {
        "title": "Caltech AUTHORS, Zwicky 1933 work and separately attributed Andernach translation",
        "url": "https://authors.library.caltech.edu/records/858yp-34954",
        "locator": "Original linked work. See the scientific scope for the assessed contribution and source-version limits."
      }
    ],
    "roles": [
      {
        "who": "Fritz Zwicky",
        "did": "Original source-listed scientific author of this scoped work; byline does not determine effort fractions.",
        "credit": "SCIENCE"
      }
    ],
    "target": {
      "record_id": "urn:uuid:797f0999-4800-4aea-a9f6-a3abbf170a50",
      "version": 1,
      "content_hash": "sha256:7a0e630de1e3f1b9f072e7197cefb130c351e544303071f399ef4eb811a47b24"
    },
    "scientific_correctness_certified": false,
    "independent_expert_calibration": false,
    "method": "PROPRIETARY",
    "points": "260000"
  },
  "canonical_agent_submission": false,
  "scientific_verification_awarded": false,
  "reader_guide": null,
  "reading_status": "SOURCE_LINKED_NOTE"
}