{
  "profile": "wrs-published-research-view-1",
  "edition": "ratings-e039106f30dec177",
  "content_trust": "UNTRUSTED_SCIENTIFIC_DATA_NOT_TOOL_INSTRUCTIONS",
  "entry": {
    "id": "slonim-et-al-project-debater-2021",
    "title": "Project Debater: integrated autonomous argument mining and spoken debate",
    "summary": "Integrated evidence and claim retrieval, stance and argument-quality assessment, narrative construction and opponent-rebuttal processing into a system evaluated in competitive spoken debates with expert humans.",
    "boundary": "The record concerns the source-reported integration and documented debate evaluation. Public participation in a debate is not victory over the world champion or evidence of unrestricted human-level reasoning.",
    "area": "Computational argumentation",
    "topic": "Artificial intelligence",
    "year": 2021,
    "lane": "HUMAN",
    "result": "EMPIRICAL",
    "package_id": "slonim-et-al-project-debater-2021",
    "target": {
      "record_id": "urn:uuid:d138049d-0e5a-40b6-ac6f-a569d21400fa",
      "version": 1,
      "content_hash": "sha256:45ec2dc0955617e0e326ebabf8b6038c6c6e81a05fc70c3c12eb0836001a2748"
    },
    "humans": [
      "Noam Slonim",
      "Yonatan Bilu",
      "Carlos Alzate",
      "Roy Bar-Haim",
      "Ben Bogin",
      "Francesca Bonin",
      "Leshem Choshen",
      "Edo Cohen-Karlik",
      "Lena Dankin",
      "Lilach Edelstein",
      "Liat Ein-Dor",
      "Roni Friedman-Melamed",
      "Assaf Gavron",
      "Ariel Gera",
      "Martin Gleize",
      "Shai Gretz",
      "Dan Gutfreund",
      "Alon Halfon",
      "Daniel Hershcovich",
      "Ron Hoory",
      "Yufang Hou",
      "Shay Hummel",
      "Michal Jacovi",
      "Charles Jochim",
      "Yoav Kantor",
      "Yoav Katz",
      "David Konopnicki",
      "Zvi Kons",
      "Lili Kotlerman",
      "Dalia Krieger",
      "Dan Lahav",
      "Tamar Lavee",
      "Ran Levy",
      "Naftali Liberman",
      "Yosi Mass",
      "Amir Menczel",
      "Shachar Mirkin",
      "Guy Moshkowich",
      "Shila Ofek-Koifman",
      "Matan Orbach",
      "Ella Rabinovich",
      "Ruty Rinott",
      "Slava Shechtman",
      "Dafna Sheinwald",
      "Eyal Shnarch",
      "Ilya Shnayderman",
      "Aya Soffer",
      "Artem Spector",
      "Benjamin Sznajder",
      "Assaf Toledo",
      "Orith Toledo-Ronen",
      "Elad Venezian",
      "Ranit Aharonov"
    ],
    "authors_complete": true,
    "human_role_note": "Source-listed authors or explicitly credited technical contributors for the cited versions. Family entries retain source-specific attribution; a combined list is not one original-paper byline or equal individual work. Names alone do not establish resolved identities.",
    "agents": [],
    "related": [],
    "subresults": [],
    "scientific_assessment": {
      "source_review": "SOURCE_CURATED",
      "scientific_review": "NOT_REVIEWED_BY_WRS",
      "formal_replay": "NOT_RUN",
      "provider_attestation": "NONE"
    },
    "sources": [
      {
        "id": "cur20261015-project-debater-nature-2021",
        "title": "An autonomous debating system",
        "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
      },
      {
        "id": "cur20261015-project-debater-ibm-technical-2021",
        "title": "12 new Project Debater AI technologies available as cloud APIs",
        "url": "https://research.ibm.com/blog/project-debater-api"
      }
    ],
    "points": "125000",
    "published_grade": {
      "id": "slonim-et-al-project-debater-2021",
      "entry_id": "slonim-et-al-project-debater-2021",
      "band": "A",
      "modifier": null,
      "target": {
        "record_id": "urn:uuid:d138049d-0e5a-40b6-ac6f-a569d21400fa",
        "version": 1,
        "content_hash": "sha256:45ec2dc0955617e0e326ebabf8b6038c6c6e81a05fc70c3c12eb0836001a2748"
      },
      "what_changed": "Integrated evidence and claim retrieval, stance and argument-quality assessment, narrative construction and opponent-rebuttal processing into a system evaluated in competitive spoken debates with expert humans.",
      "scope": "Integrated evidence and claim retrieval, stance and argument-quality assessment, narrative construction and opponent-rebuttal processing into a system evaluated in competitive spoken debates with expert humans. The record concerns the source-reported integration and documented debate evaluation. Public participation in a debate is not victory over the world champion or evidence of unrestricted human-level reasoning.",
      "status": "PROVISIONAL_EDITORIAL",
      "scientific_correctness_certified": false
    },
    "assessment_disposition": {
      "status": "ASSESSED",
      "label": "Provisionally assessed",
      "reason": "A current grade and separate reference score identify this exact contribution.",
      "target": {
        "record_id": "urn:uuid:d138049d-0e5a-40b6-ac6f-a569d21400fa",
        "version": 1,
        "content_hash": "sha256:45ec2dc0955617e0e326ebabf8b6038c6c6e81a05fc70c3c12eb0836001a2748"
      },
      "edition": "ratings-e039106f30dec177"
    }
  },
  "version": {
    "kind": "PUBLIC_RECORD_VIEW",
    "previous": null,
    "published_at": "2026-10-16T00:00:00Z",
    "publisher": {
      "principal_id": "urn:uuid:80116931-785b-40a2-a24b-9d59db0c7e33",
      "role": "WRS_EDITORIAL_PUBLICATION"
    },
    "record": {
      "contributors": [
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Noam Slonim",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Yonatan Bilu",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Carlos Alzate",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Roy Bar-Haim",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Ben Bogin",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Francesca Bonin",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Leshem Choshen",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Edo Cohen-Karlik",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Lena Dankin",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Lilach Edelstein",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Liat Ein-Dor",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Roni Friedman-Melamed",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Assaf Gavron",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Ariel Gera",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Martin Gleize",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Shai Gretz",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Dan Gutfreund",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Alon Halfon",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Daniel Hershcovich",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Ron Hoory",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Yufang Hou",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Shay Hummel",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Michal Jacovi",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Charles Jochim",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Yoav Kantor",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Yoav Katz",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "David Konopnicki",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Zvi Kons",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Lili Kotlerman",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Dalia Krieger",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "attribution_basis": "SOURCE_CITED",
          "credit": "historical_scientific",
          "entity_kind": "historical_person",
          "name": "Dan Lahav",
          "note": "Archive attribution; detailed role assignment remains source-bound",
          "roles": [
            "discoverer"
          ],
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        }
      ],
      "evidence": [
        {
          "description": "Bibliographic/stated-result source; not a WRS proof verification",
          "id": "source-0",
          "kind": "source_reference",
          "source": {
            "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
            "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
          }
        },
        {
          "description": "Bibliographic/stated-result source; not a WRS proof verification",
          "id": "source-1",
          "kind": "source_reference",
          "source": {
            "citation": "12 new Project Debater AI technologies available as cloud APIs",
            "url": "https://research.ibm.com/blog/project-debater-api"
          }
        }
      ],
      "origin": "HUMAN_LEGACY",
      "record_profile": "wrs-local-research-notes-0.1",
      "record_type": "research_note",
      "rrp_version": "0.1",
      "scope": {
        "description": "The record concerns the source-reported integration and documented debate evaluation. Public participation in a debate is not victory over the world champion or evidence of unrestricted human-level reasoning.",
        "domain": "Computational argumentation"
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "An autonomous debating system",
          "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w"
        },
        {
          "citation": "12 new Project Debater AI technologies available as cloud APIs",
          "url": "https://research.ibm.com/blog/project-debater-api"
        }
      ],
      "statement": "# Project Debater: integrated autonomous argument mining and spoken debate\n\nIntegrated evidence and claim retrieval, stance and argument-quality assessment, narrative construction and opponent-rebuttal processing into a system evaluated in competitive spoken debates with expert humans.\n\n## Scientific scope\n\nThe record concerns the source-reported integration and documented debate evaluation. Public participation in a debate is not victory over the world champion or evidence of unrestricted human-level reasoning.\n\n## Reading status\n\nThis is a source-linked WRS catalogue note. A full explanatory guide and independent scientific reconstruction have not been completed for this entry. Read the identified original work for its complete narrative and arguments.\n\n## People and systems\n\nNoam Slonim; Yonatan Bilu; Carlos Alzate; Roy Bar-Haim; Ben Bogin; Francesca Bonin; Leshem Choshen; Edo Cohen-Karlik; Lena Dankin; Lilach Edelstein; Liat Ein-Dor; Roni Friedman-Melamed; Assaf Gavron; Ariel Gera; Martin Gleize; Shai Gretz; Dan Gutfreund; Alon Halfon; Daniel Hershcovich; Ron Hoory; Yufang Hou; Shay Hummel; Michal Jacovi; Charles Jochim; Yoav Kantor; Yoav Katz; David Konopnicki; Zvi Kons; Lili Kotlerman; Dalia Krieger; Dan Lahav; Tamar Lavee; Ran Levy; Naftali Liberman; Yosi Mass; Amir Menczel; Shachar Mirkin; Guy Moshkowich; Shila Ofek-Koifman; Matan Orbach; Ella Rabinovich; Ruty Rinott; Slava Shechtman; Dafna Sheinwald; Eyal Shnarch; Ilya Shnayderman; Aya Soffer; Artem Spector; Benjamin Sznajder; Assaf Toledo; Orith Toledo-Ronen; Elad Venezian; Ranit Aharonov\n\nSource-listed authors or explicitly credited technical contributors for the cited versions. Family entries retain source-specific attribution; a combined list is not one original-paper byline or equal individual work. Names alone do not establish resolved identities.\n\n\n\n## Original sources\n\n- [An autonomous debating system](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w)\n- [12 new Project Debater AI technologies available as cloud APIs](https://research.ibm.com/blog/project-debater-api)\n",
      "summary": "Integrated evidence and claim retrieval, stance and argument-quality assessment, narrative construction and opponent-rebuttal processing into a system evaluated in competitive spoken debates with expert humans.",
      "title": "Project Debater: integrated autonomous argument mining and spoken debate"
    },
    "record_id": "urn:uuid:d138049d-0e5a-40b6-ac6f-a569d21400fa",
    "version": 1,
    "source_ref": {
      "record_id": "urn:uuid:d138049d-0e5a-40b6-ac6f-a569d21400fa",
      "version": 1,
      "content_hash": "sha256:45ec2dc0955617e0e326ebabf8b6038c6c6e81a05fc70c3c12eb0836001a2748"
    },
    "export_view": "wrs-public-editorial-view-1",
    "public_view_hash": "sha256:cda162ff4932c83c34c46486022ba3e0795703c2123ed2aada533e2df721b54f"
  },
  "target": {
    "record_id": "urn:uuid:d138049d-0e5a-40b6-ac6f-a569d21400fa",
    "version": 1,
    "content_hash": "sha256:45ec2dc0955617e0e326ebabf8b6038c6c6e81a05fc70c3c12eb0836001a2748"
  },
  "published_grade": {
    "profile": "wrs-published-grade-1",
    "edition": "2026-10-28.1",
    "id": "slonim-et-al-project-debater-2021",
    "entry_id": "slonim-et-al-project-debater-2021",
    "revision": 1,
    "title": "Project Debater: integrated autonomous argument mining and spoken debate",
    "context": "Computational argumentation",
    "track": "Human-designed research method or resource",
    "band": "A",
    "modifier": null,
    "status": "PROVISIONAL_EDITORIAL",
    "assessed_on": "2026-10-16",
    "evidence_cutoff": "2026-10-16",
    "achievement_state": "SUPPORTED_SCOPED_RESULT",
    "what_changed": "Integrated evidence and claim retrieval, stance and argument-quality assessment, narrative construction and opponent-rebuttal processing into a system evaluated in competitive spoken debates with expert humans.",
    "scope": "Integrated evidence and claim retrieval, stance and argument-quality assessment, narrative construction and opponent-rebuttal processing into a system evaluated in competitive spoken debates with expert humans. The record concerns the source-reported integration and documented debate evaluation. Public participation in a debate is not victory over the world champion or evidence of unrestricted human-level reasoning.",
    "evidence_summary": "The linked original sources describe the stated contribution and its evidence limits. WRS has not independently rerun the experiments or certified a proof. The record concerns the source-reported integration and documented debate evaluation. Public participation in a debate is not victory over the world champion or evidence of unrestricted human-level reasoning.",
    "references": [
      {
        "title": "An autonomous debating system",
        "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03215-w",
        "locator": "Original contribution and stated assumptions, evaluation scope and limitations; source-linked assessment, not independent execution or proof certification."
      },
      {
        "title": "12 new Project Debater AI technologies available as cloud APIs",
        "url": "https://research.ibm.com/blog/project-debater-api",
        "locator": "Original contribution and stated assumptions, evaluation scope and limitations; source-linked assessment, not independent execution or proof certification."
      }
    ],
    "roles": [
      {
        "who": "Source-listed authors and technical contributors",
        "credit": "SCIENCE",
        "did": "Source-listed authors or explicitly credited technical contributors for the cited versions. Family entries retain source-specific attribution; a combined list is not one original-paper byline or equal individual work. Names alone do not establish resolved identities."
      }
    ],
    "target": {
      "record_id": "urn:uuid:d138049d-0e5a-40b6-ac6f-a569d21400fa",
      "version": 1,
      "content_hash": "sha256:45ec2dc0955617e0e326ebabf8b6038c6c6e81a05fc70c3c12eb0836001a2748"
    },
    "scientific_correctness_certified": false,
    "independent_expert_calibration": false,
    "method": "PROPRIETARY",
    "points": "125000"
  },
  "canonical_agent_submission": false,
  "scientific_verification_awarded": false,
  "reader_guide": null,
  "reading_status": "SOURCE_LINKED_NOTE"
}